P11Ds Are Changing: What Employers Must Do Before April 2027
HMRC published new guidance in November 2026 on how benefits in kind will be reported from April 2027. If you give an employee a company car, a van, fuel or private medical insurance, the way you report it is about to change. From 6 April 2027 those benefits go through your payroll instead of on a P11D, and the tax comes off as you pay people rather than months later.
There are two deadlines in early April 2027 that are easy to miss, and one more P11D round to get through before any of it starts. Here is what changes and what to do about it.
What is changing, and when
The change comes in two phases.
| Benefit | 2026 to 2027 | April 2027 | April 2028 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Company cars and car fuel | P11D | Payroll | Payroll |
| Company vans and van fuel | P11D | Payroll | Payroll |
| Private medical insurance | P11D | Payroll | Payroll |
| Most other benefits | P11D | Your choice | Payroll |
| Beneficial loans | P11D | Your choice | Your choice |
| Living accommodation | P11D | Your choice | Your choice |
“Payroll” means you must report it through payroll; “your choice” means you can leave it on a P11D or payroll it if you would rather.
Loans and living accommodation are the two that stay outside the compulsory rules for now. The government has said it will set out a timeline for those later.
HMRC's detailed guidance is still being written. The draft legislation is due to go into its manual in December 2026, so some of the finer points are not settled yet.
What it means in practice
A payrolled benefit is reported on your Full Payment Submission each time you run payroll, like pay itself. Four things follow from that.
- The tax comes off during the year. At the moment the tax on a benefit is usually collected through the employee's tax code, often a year or more after they got the benefit. From April 2027 it comes off their pay as they go.
- Employer's National Insurance comes off in real time too. Class 1A National Insurance on those benefits is deducted through payroll each pay period, rather than being worked out after the year end and paid in one go in July.
- Tax codes change. HMRC will take the benefit adjustments out of employees' tax codes, because the tax is being collected elsewhere.
- No P11D for those benefits. Anything you payroll does not go on a P11D or P11D(b).
Your staff will notice. Their tax code will change, their payslip will show something new and their take-home pay may move. They are not paying more tax overall, just paying it at a different time, and that is worth saying plainly before the first payslip lands. After the year end you give each of them a statement of the benefits that went through payroll.
You still have one more P11D to do
None of this changes the 2026 to 2027 tax year. Benefits given in that year are reported the old way:
- P11D and P11D(b) by 6 July 2027, with a copy of the P11D to each employee by the same date.
- Class 1A National Insurance paid by 22 July 2027 if you pay electronically, or 19 July if you pay by cheque.
- A late P11D(b) costs £100 per 50 employees for each month or part month it is late.
So the summer of 2027 is busy: the last P11D round for 2026 to 2027 lands in July, while the new real-time reporting is already running for 2027 to 2028.
Will anyone be taxed twice?
No. Nobody pays tax twice on the same benefit. But for one year it can look that way on a payslip, so it is worth explaining before anyone sees it.
From April 2027 the tax on this year's benefits comes out of pay as it is earned. Tax owed on 2026 to 2027 benefits is a separate thing: it can only be worked out once that year has ended and the P11D is in, and HMRC collects it the way it always has. HMRC has confirmed that an underpayment from an earlier year stays in the tax code even when the benefit adjustment is taken out of it.
So an employee can meet both at once: this year's benefit tax in their payslip, and last year's still being collected through their code. That is two different years arriving together, not the same benefit taxed twice. Once the older amount is paid off, benefit tax is simply paid in the year the benefit is given.
The same overlap lands on the employer's bank account. Class 1A on 2026 to 2027 benefits is still one payment due by 22 July 2027, while Class 1A on 2027 to 2028 benefits is already coming out every pay period. It is worth planning for in that first year.
Two deadlines on 5 April 2027
1. Registering to payroll your other benefits
You do not need to register for the benefits that become compulsory. You do need to register if you want to payroll anything else voluntarily, and you have to do it before the tax year starts. You cannot change how you report a benefit partway through a year.
HMRC reopened its online registration service in November 2026, and for the first time living accommodation and beneficial loans can be payrolled too. If you have a director's loan or a flat above the shop that has always gone on a P11D, that is new.
2. Applying for an exception
There is one exception to compulsory payrolling, for employees who are genuinely globally mobile and whose benefits you will not have enough information to payroll. If that applies to someone, you must apply by 5 April 2027. Three things to know:
- An exception cannot be backdated, so apply as soon as you know.
- It covers all of that employee's benefits. You cannot payroll some and put others on a P11D.
- Short business trips, the odd overseas meeting or working abroad for a while do not usually count.
What to do now
- List what you report today. Go through last year's P11Ds and mark which benefits fall into the April 2027 group.
- Ask your payroll software provider. Check they will be ready for the new reporting, and when their update lands.
- Decide about your other benefits. If you would rather payroll everything at once than run both systems, register before 5 April 2027.
- Check for anyone globally mobile and apply for an exception in good time.
- Budget for the cash flow change. Class 1A on cars, vans, fuel and medical cover moves from one payment in July to a bit every pay period.
- Tell your staff before April. Explain the tax code change, that they are not worse off, and that anyone who still owes tax on an earlier year's benefits may see both for a while. It saves a lot of questions at the first payslip of the year.
- Get the 2026 to 2027 P11Ds done on time. The old deadlines still apply in July 2027.
How Officium can help
We run payroll for small employers, so this is our job rather than yours. We can go through your benefits and tell you which ones move in April 2027, get your payroll ready, handle the registrations and exceptions before the April deadlines, write to your staff for you, and file your 2026 to 2027 P11Ds in July.
Call us on 01942 644864 or email hello@officiumbusinessservices.co.uk to talk it through.
This article is general guidance based on GOV.UK and HMRC information as at 18 November 2026. HMRC's detailed guidance and draft legislation are still being published, so some points may change. It is not advice for your specific circumstances.